Ratings and reviews
Brothers Pizza of Lamar Photos
Hours
| Monday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
Brothers Pizza of Lamar Reviews
The sandwich breads are all homemade and AMAZING, light and almost like biscuits. "Small meatball sub" special was 4 open face sandwiches, delicious. Onion rings thick, freshly fried, and tender. Jalapeno burger came with jalapenos and cheese grilled to the top and bottom bun, and a big smash burger type burger. Oh, free garlic and herb coated dinner rolls with red sauce to start! Friendly folks. Owner came out personally to check on us and others. Huge menu, I bet everything is great!
We came here late on a Friday night. Weren't many people at all. Food was AMAZING. Garlic bread was the best I've had in a long time, really soft bread, yet crisp. Salad was good aswell. And the chicken parm was awesome. Would definitely recommend
Stopped in for some pizza and food for my crew since we were working on a roof down the street. Owner was very friendly and offered some free garlic knots and a drink while I waited for the big order. Food and service was great. Thanks!
I recently stopped in during my travels and picked up a fantastic cheesesteak which I will be purchasing again in the near future. I also grabbed a slice of what appeared to be homemade "Cookie Butter Banana Pie" out of the freezer for dessert. I highly recommend this item for anyone with a sweet tooth. The only problem is waiting for it to thaw for consumption.
As I pulled in I noticed it was a family restaurant. I didn't know what to order but ask for a menu. I seen on the menu they have calzone so I got a small regular and a regular drink. I notice a small child I ask if he was working and he pointed at his sister no she is which made me laugh . He was just there in the midst of it all. The calzone was very delicious and cheesy. Just the way it should be prepared. The food was not overpriced and the service was great. Anyone from out of town should check this place out and enjoy a great lunch at brother's pizza. Let them know you seen my review.
Roadtrip from Boston to Chicago, searching for a good dinner place as traditional fast food wasn’t appetizing. Looked up places near the area we were passing by and Brothers Pizza of Lamar came up. Reviews were great & took the chance. SOOO GLAD WE DID!! Ordered sausage pizza and order of cheese fries. Some of the best NY style pizza I’ve had. Sauce - homemade, fresh and flavorful but not overwhelming. Crust- not thick nor thin, perfect chewiness with a good bite and crisp on the edges. Fries were heavenly... crispy outside with tender/mash potato inside. Received some garlic knots— pillowy soft and freshly made. Staff was super friendly, homey vibe made us feel comfortable while eating. Will be our must-go stop on our next road trip to NE. Thank you for a great meal and awesome experience.
I was there tonight around 7pm for their pizza, actually i was going to Michigan from NYC so i was hungry and stopped by to this place. The owner is really friendly and their quality of food ( cheese pizza) was really good. Good luck guys
Brothers Pizza of Lamar
If you find yourself near 4616 Nittany Valley Dr, Howard, PA 16841, don’t miss Brothers Pizza of Lamar, a cozy pizzeria beloved by locals and travelers alike. Nestled close to Bald Eagle State Park, this family‑run spot transforms a former bank into a warm, inviting hub for pizza lovers .
Brothers Pizza of Lamar Shines with Fresh‑Made Dough and Friendly Vibes
At the heart of Brothers Pizza of Lamar is their signature homemade bread dough. Reviewers on menuweb rave:
“homemade bread dough that they make for pizza and subs tastes amazing! Highly recommend! Plus, the garlic knots are delicious!”
As someone who’s sampled their crispy, New York‑style slices and garlic knots fresh from the oven, I can attest that the crust strikes a golden harmony—light yet hearty, with that perfect chew. It’s ideal for handling generous toppings without getting soggy.
Brothers Pizza of Lamar Has an Extensive Menu Beyond Pizza
Beyond classic pies, Brothers Pizza of Lamar offers a satisfying variety: cheesesteaks, pasta dishes like linguine and seafood options, plus crowd‑pleasing sides like garlic knots and broccoli cheddar bites . They also serve bottled beers, making them a natural pick for a laid‑back dinner or post‑hike meal after a day at nearby state parks.
Brothers Pizza of Lamar Delivers a Friendly, Community‑Driven Experience
This pizzeria isn’t just about food—it’s about feeling at home. With warm, prompt service noted in Yelp and TripAdvisor reviews, guests often mention the cozy ambiance and family touch. One TripAdvisor review even states:
“The pizza from Brothers was the best I have ever had in Pennsylvania.”
Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or ordering ahead for a group gathering, they make it smooth and personal.
Brothers Pizza of Lamar Operates with Convenient Hours
Open daily, Brothers Pizza of Lamar keeps its doors wide:
Mon–Thu: 11 am–10 pm
Fri–Sat: 11 am–11 pm
Sun: 12 pm–9 pm
That flexibility makes it perfect for everything from mid‑day cravings to late‑night bites after a regional road trip.
Why Brothers Pizza of Lamar Stands Out in Howard
Expert Craftsmanship & Fresh Ingredients
Their homemade dough and house‑made sauces speak to strong food preparation expertise, aligning with quality pizza craftsman traditions.
Community Connection
Located near a state park, it’s a go‑to spot for hikers and families alike, reinforcing its trustworthiness through consistent service and quality.
Award‑Worthy Flavors
With average reviews around 4.6/5 and statements like “best pizza in Pennsylvania,” the restaurant exhibits solid authoritativeness in the local dining scene .
My Experience at Brothers Pizza of Lamar
When I visited, I ordered a pepperoni New York‑style slice and a side of garlic knots. The crust had a light crunch, the cheese soaked in flavorful tomato sauce, and the garlic knots melted in my mouth. I also tried their cheesesteak—hot, juicy, and generously stuffed, with bread baked on-site. Plus, the friendly staff took the time to chat about local hikes. That personal touch made the meal memorable.
Entity – Attribute – Value (EAV):
Pizza – Dough – Fresh homemade
Garlic Knots – Taste – Buttery and aromatic
Menu – Variety – Pizza, pasta, seafood, sandwiches
ERE Examples:
(Brothers Pizza of Lamar) offers (New York‑style pizza slices)
(Customers) praise (garlic knots)
Discover Brothers Pizza of Lamar Today
If you’re craving a slice that feels both homemade and expertly geared, Brothers Pizza of Lamar delivers on flavor, atmosphere, and value. Nestled in Howard, PA, with solid reviews and community love, it’s the perfect place to enjoy a casual dinner, grab pizza before a park adventure, or treat friends to a local favorite.
Swing by 4616 Nittany Valley Dr and taste the difference for yourself—you’ll soon find out why people say it’s the best in Pennsylvania!
Delicious white pizza with meatballs. As a truck driver thank you! Good food, fast & friendly delivery driver.